HyrePlumber

Comparison

Pedestal vs submersible sump pump

Both empty the same pit. One keeps its motor dry above the water; the other sits in it.

HyrePlumber Research team Published Last updated

Pedestal vs submersible sump pump is about where the motor sits. A pedestal pump has its motor on a column above the pit, so it stays dry and its switch is easy to see. A submersible pump sits whole at the bottom of the pit, under water. NDSU Extension says either type works well with proper maintenance.

The more important choices are often the switch, the check valve and where the water goes. NDSU calls a sealed float switch generally more reliable on a submersible. See sump pump for testing and discharge.

Pedestal vs Submersible: side-by-side table

From NDSU Extension’s Sump Pump Questions and FEMA’s basement flooding guidance.

FactorPedestalSubmersible
MotorAbove the pit on a column; must stay dryIn the water at the bottom of the pit
SwitchFloat rod and switch, easy to seeFloat on a pressure switch, or a sealed float switch
PitSuits small or narrow pitsNeeds a pit wide and deep enough for the pump; check the manual
CoverPit cannot be fully sealed around the columnPit can take a sealed lid
ServiceMotor reachable without pulling the pumpPump lifted out for service
Shared by bothCheck valve on the outlet; GFCI-protected outlet advised; discharge away from the houseSame

When a pedestal pump is the right call

A pedestal pump fits a small pit, or an owner who wants to see the switch and reach the motor.

  • A narrow or shallow pit a submersible will not fit.
  • Easy inspection of the float and switch.
  • A basement where the open pit is not a concern.

When a submersible pump is the right call

A submersible pump fits a finished basement or a pit that should be covered.

  • A finished basement where a pump column would be in the way.
  • A pit that should take a sealed lid, for safety or radon reasons; ask your installer.
  • Replacing an existing submersible like-for-like; NDSU says most homeowners can replace a failed pump of the same type.

Where the water goes matters more than the pump

NDSU Extension says discharge should go at least 20 feet from the house, draining away, and never into a floor drain or the sanitary sewer. Many cities ban sump connections to the sewer. Ask your city before changing a discharge line.

What moves the cost of either

What moves the price of either pump is the pit and the plumbing around it.

  • Pump size read from the maker’s flow chart at your lift height; NDSU says 1/3 hp suits most houses.
  • Pit: reusing it, enlarging it or adding a liner.
  • Check valve, union and discharge line.
  • Electrical: a GFCI-protected outlet nearby.
  • A backup pump or alarm added at the same time.

HyrePlumber publishes no prices for this work until it holds enough sourced, dated quotes. See how plumbing is priced, check a bid with the plumbing quote checker, and read how to choose a plumber before you hire.

Sources

  1. NDSU Extension, via North Dakota Department of Emergency Services, Sump Pump Questions. Retrieved October 12, 2026.
  2. FEMA, Mitigation and Basement Flooding (2008 presentation, hosted by WVU GIS). Retrieved October 12, 2026.

Questions people ask

Is a pedestal or submersible sump pump better?
NDSU Extension says either works well with proper maintenance. Pedestals suit small pits and easy service; submersibles suit covered pits and finished basements.
Which sump pump lasts longer?
HyrePlumber has no primary source that compares the two on lifespan, so we do not claim one outlasts the other. Testing before the wet season matters more.
What size sump pump do I need?
NDSU says a 1/3 hp pump suits most houses. Read the maker’s flow chart at your lift height rather than going by horsepower.
How do I test a sump pump?
Pour water slowly into the pit until the pump cycles at least twice. NDSU suggests about 5 gallons. Do it before the wet season.

Related